MarkKO wrote: ↑Thu Jan 19, 2023 11:58 pm
Renascent wrote: ↑Thu Jan 19, 2023 6:50 pm
MarkKO wrote: ↑Thu Jan 19, 2023 6:33 pm
dw wrote: ↑Thu Jan 19, 2023 5:10 pm
Loved RDR so much, just exploring that world. Going to play the sequel as soon as I get a new GPU.
I've never given it a shot but I'm tempted. There are very few games I've played for more than a day or two.
I'd recommend it. It's a game you can step away from when you need to come back to reality, but, for the sake of immersion, I wouldn't stay away from it for too long between sessions.
So, follow up question. In style how does it compare to Fallout 4 and Skyrim? Other than Destiny 2 those are the only vaguely modern games I've devoted any amount of time to. I think what's held me back from RDR is that I've often heard it described at GTA in the Old West.
I've not yet played any Fallout games. I have a copy of Skyrim that I still intend to get to someday, but I've only seen my stepdaughter play it, in passing. I remember her character going to jail for getting caught stealing some silverware or something, so perhaps Red Dead Redemption is more in line, stylistically, with Skyrim.
Way back when (2005?), I picked up a copy of Red Dead Revolver about a year after it was released, with the expectation that it was basically GTA with horses. Instead, it turned out to be something like a 3D homage to the western-themed shooters of the 80's (like Wild Gunman, or Hogan's Alley), but with a Tarantino-esque presentation. I enjoyed the hell out of it, and still have songs from the soundtrack on my MP3 player.
Before I played Red Dead Redemption, I half-expected it to be a more realized version of the "GTA on horses" sort of game that everyone was clamoring for prior to its release. It definitely shares similarities with other Rockstar games, where presentation and gameplay are concerned, but it felt less like GTA than I thought it would. Mind you, I played a pretty straight-laced style; anybody I saw beating up prostitutes got shot on sight, and the one time I hogtied someone and placed them on the train tracks (he was a horse thief), I ended up letting him go (I got impatient waiting on the train). Most of the time, I'd even restart missions if I accidentally capped my horse during bear hunts and bounty hunter shit. I steered clear of the law's bad side.
For what it's worth, I didn't really enjoy GTA V as much as I thought I would; it seemed like the more they tried to make the world feel more realistic, the more I noticed what was lacking in the game (I had infinitely more fun in San Andreas when trying to "outsmart" the design of the game, and it felt less restrictive). Plus, I didn't find any of the characters particularly likeable, and the storyline was kinda meh. Even causing chaos felt sort of restricted, unless I was doing it wrong.
Maybe Red Dead Redemption has the benefit of being a 13-year-old game, so my expectations were a little tempered, but the story was engaging enough, and there was something very satisfying about even just riding around on the horse through Mexico. Taking over gang hideouts and bear hunting was oddly very gratifying. I might play Undead Nightmare next before moving on to something else.